Modcloth is a great site.
I feel, if you don't want to even bother to make something in my size, or its not "properly" in my size, I should be able to replicate the garment.
Theoretically, they could make every main size range under the rainbow. (sizes 0-32+). But they choose to make sizes 0-12 or 0-10, catering only to a few customers. It is within their legal right, yes, but it is unfair to other potential customers.